PropertyReal Estate

OSCARS TAKE THE TAYLOR SQUARE TWINS

Bill and Mario Gravanis’ Oscars Group has snapped up the landmark and controversial Taylor Square twins Kinselas and The Courthouse Hotel, from MA Financial’s special pub fund.

The brothers have reportedly paid $54 million for the two big Darlinghurst pubs plus adjoining retail shops at 379–381 Bourke Street, for a combined holding of 1,050sqm, with three street frontages.

The venues provide a broad mix of hospitality facilities, including sports bars, gaming rooms counting 43 EGMs, a bistro, function rooms and nightclub spaces, and 12 recently renovated accommodation rooms. 

Oscars will incorporate them into its broader portfolio and is planning a “long-term strategic vision” for the Taylor Square block. 

The Group has been tweaking the collection this year, selling its share of the Tamworth Pub Group in March as part of a $160 million transaction to IMG, and the following month taking the South Terrace Hotel in Bankstown from Redcape for $54 million.

Last month they reversed the parties, selling back to Redcape the Caves Beach Hotel and bungalows, for circa $40 million.

MA Financial created the Taylor Square Fund in 2020, buying the Courthouse Hotel in November that year for $22 million. The following month they launched a thousand theories with purchase of Oxford strip icon Kinselas, paying $45 million.

After several years not capitalising on the precinct purchases MAF agreed to sell the pair of pubs to growing industry speculator Virtical, for a not insignificant loss total of $61 million.

However, the rapidly expanding Virtical began to stumble and failed to finalise the extended settlement. By mid-2024 MAF had taken the matter to the Supreme Court, and judgement in August saw the purchaser ordered to pay up.

This came as the Australian Taxation Office was investigating Virtical directors John Palasty and Mark Toma over millions of dollars in allegedly falsified GST claims.

Meanwhile, the Taylor Square Fund continued to hold the assets, although 11 gaming entitlements were sold, which reduced the hotels’ value.

Redcape CEO and MA Financial’s Head of Hospitality, Chris Unger, explained the assets are outside of the Redcape portfolio, and the stand-alone fund “has come to its maturity”. 

The deal was managed by JLL Hotels’ John Musca, who explained the lower sale price was offset by the sale of the EGMs and that Virtical forfeited its deposit in the failed sale three years ago.

He says gaming-entitled venues in coveted, high-foot-traffic precincts such as Taylor Square continue to command premium pricing, and that despite “mid-terms, wars, COVID or economic turbulence” pubs continue to deliver significant cash flow growth, compared with many other real estate asset classes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *